
Rather than write one of my holier-than-thou (or at least holier-than-Pitchfork) reviews upon immediate download of the leak, replete with fairly obvious observations and criticisms, I have waited until now to write about Brand New’s Daisy. They deserve better than a simple knee-jerk reaction of a write-up.
Here is a brief summary of my initial thoughts upon first listening to the album over a month ago:
- Yes, the album is abound with twangy nods to early 90s grunge
- Yes, it is some of the band’s “hardest” music to date
- Yes, it is an album that begs to be played live
- No, Jesse Lacey does not sound like Isaac Brock
- No, this is not Brand New’s In Utero
- No, Brand New does not sound like The Jesus Lizard, but the influence certainly is there
After reading a few interviews with both Lacey and guitarist Vincent Accardi (who wrote much of the album), I am no closer to solving the mystery of the country-fried vocal chords. What a caper! The album was not recorded in a woodshed emblazoned with the confederate flag, nor did the band listen to bluegrass albums during the writing and recording processes. Rather, Daisy was recorded in long-time collaborator/producer Mike Sappone’s Long Island, NY house and the band listened to an eclectic mix of music (including gospel singer Bertrand Brown, whose hymn “On Life’s Highway” bookends the album) that was available to them in Sappone’s basement. So, I am not quite sure what accounts for Lacey’s country cook-off vocal style throughout the album.
Although Daisy certainly is a hard-hitting album and arguably Brand New’s most aggressive one to date, it also features some of their softest songs. Whereas “Vices,” “Gasoline,” and “Sink” are relentlessly vicious tracks that find Lacey screaming the choruses, tracks like “Bed,” “Daisy,” and “Be Gone” are some of the band’s softest. The more subdued tracks on Daisy avoid the “classic” Brand New formula of building into a climactic, loud, crescendo of an ending and instead stay the course of remaining a more gentle song throughout.
The only typically Brand New track on the album, I suppose, is “You Stole.” Its slow building, palm muted verse is reminiscent of “Okay I believe you but my tommy gun don’t” from Deja Entendu. However, it does not have that deliberate, “this is the climax! Right….NOW!” aspect that the Brand New songs from days of yore posses. Yes, the drums kick in a minute or so into the song and eventually there is a more intense instrumental break, but the song travels along a specific trajectory that does not emphasize any one part too much more than any other.
In regards to the overall grunginess of the album, anyone who has seen Brand New live over the past few years should not be too surprised. The band has always tended to get quite heavy live and Lacey would always scream far more than on record. As I noted upon initially listening to Daisy, this album begs to be played live, especially by a band that puts on an intense live show to begin with. Lacey confirmed in interviews that one of the goals the band had in mind while recording the album was to craft an album that will translate well live.
Both Deja Entendu and The Devil and God Are Raging Inside Me are emotionally draining albums, both lyrically and musically. The latter especially deals with dark, solemn subject matter (not to suggest that Daisy does not). Both of these albums are just that, albums—a unified collection of songs that have a cohesive, carefully thought-out order, structure, and flow. I do not find Daisy to be as much of an album as it is a collection of songs. I do not suggest that the track order was not carefully considered, nor do I suggest that it is not in fact a fairly unified collection of songs that are aesthetically and thematically similar. Furthermore, I do not suggest that one should not listen to Daisy in its entirety from start to finish. Finally, I do not suggest that the split apart hymn that bookends the album is irrelevant or not a type of unifying concept. However, Vincent Accardi (who, I remind you, wrote most of the album) is not quite the auteur that Jesse Lacey is. I mean this in both the lyrical and musical sense.
The Devil and God… has a narrative flow both in subject matter and musical arrangement (with the exception of “The Archers Bows Have Broken,” which I find to be oddly out of place). Ditto for Deja Entendu. I find Daisy to lack that narrative and thus lack in terms of its completeness as a true album. It is still a finely crafted collection of songs that is far better than most of the music that receives acclaim and success in the industry, written by a band that challenges itself with each subsequent album. One must appreciate the fact that Brand New aims to reach a different aesthetic with this album even if Lacey’s twangy vocals are not your cup of whiskey-spiked tea.
