Kevin,
Truth be told, I have never been too keen on Broken Social Scene (nor am I too keen on cute rhyming triplets). I have always had a like/hate relationship with so-called indie rock, which in itself has been disproportionate and unfair: My negative feelings have always been far stronger than my positive ones. For example, I enjoy Metric's
Live It Out, nearly from start to finish. On that note, I cannot even listen to a Stars album without wishing Quebec would secede from Canada and bring Montreal with it, simply so there can be a more official, internationally recognized barrier separating myself and the band (I hear slabs of concrete are great for this and have the potential to be a lucrative entry into the
nic-nac market).
That being said, the majority of what is to follow in this letter has less to do with the music you and your cohorts have made under the Broken Social Scene umbrella and more to do with something I'd like to call "racing a retired horse."
First, allow me to explain this analogy I just coined:
Arguably, horses do not posses conscious minds. Thus, they are ultimately unaware that they may be past their prime and ready to move on to the green pastures of retirement. Whilst basking in this retirement, if an unsavoury character was to dangle a carrot before the aged horse, drawing it into a race of sorts, said horse would most likely gallop forth disregarding its retirement. Why? Because, as I just explained, horses do not posses conscious minds. Therefore, an horse could not possibly know that it is in retirement.
Kevin, I sincerely hope you follow this analogy and can use the rudimentary logic most humans posses to see how it applies to Broken Social Scene.
Fine, I'll just fucking spell it out: BSS had their peak. You conquered indie rock. You are the definitive Canadian band of the 00's. You created a scene, a specific sound, a tightly-knit association of musicians. But please, I beg of you, stop the madness. Stop filling this balloon with jangly indie rock helium, otherwise it is going to burst and spew tongue-in-cheek lyrics upon the land!
The release of
Forgiveness Rock Record and companion EP
Lo-Fi For The Dividing Nights are not what the music world needs right now. Ten years ago, yes. I thought you had already passed the torch with your protege-signing of Still Life Still to Arts&Crafts. I was under the assumption that Still Life Still was the Vader to BSS's Emperor. However, based on the refusal of BSS to dignifiedly fade away, it would appear that
begun this clone war has.
Thank you for putting Toronto on the map musically. Thank you for putting out a couple of the quintessential indie rock albums of the 00's. Thank you for subduing that she-devil Feist. Now, kindly fuck off.
Yours,
This Guy.